Quantcast

Forum Login

feed image
Directory Reviews Motherboard Reviews

Final Verdict: ECS PX1 Extreme PDF Print E-mail
Article Index
Final Verdict: ECS PX1 Extreme
The Core Issue - BIOS
Benckmarks
Conclusions

Author: Scott Piercy

Editor: Nigel Woodford 

Model: ECS PX1 Extreme

smallboardpic This has been one of those situations we as editors and reviewers try to avoid. Actually working in this business is truly a careful balancing act, requiring us to be fair and balanced to everyone involved. Manufacturers naturally want their products shown in the best light, and that's understandable. Furthermore, end users have a right to be informed, and indeed without them we *and* the manufacturers would be out of a job. Since we are an enthusiast publication, we try to review products that appeal to this segment. Along these lines, quite naturally, manufacturers who create products for this segment of buyers try to cater to their needs, with varying degrees of success.

From our first "preview" last month, it's quite clear that ECS is attempting to target the enthusiast with the PX1 Extreme. We invite you to read our preview here, but it's obvious from its packaging and overall feature set that it's not intended to be a plain vanilla board. It's chocked full of features and expandability options, and one of the very few Intel P965 chipset boards that supports ATI Crossfire. As we are using this board as part of an upcoming Crossfire evaluation of the P965 chipset, we can at least let a little bit slip and say the board supports Crossfire seamlessly and with no apparent bandwidth issues from the P965's x16/x4 channel arrangement. It's also one of the few Intel VIIV compliant boards available, thanks to the ICH8DH Southbridge. Due to the complexities of VIIV licensing compliance with Intel, it's a bit odd to see the ICH8DH Southbridge on a retail channel enthusiast board, but certainly quite welcome from the standpoint of the budding home theatre buff who wants to build his own Media Center Edition HTPC.

The layout of the board itself is for the most part drama free, except for one issue that ECS brought to our attention. We'll discuss that a bit later, but from a component layout standpoint we were well pleased, and made evident that a lot of thought and care went into a logical arrangement of the boards connectors and components.

board1board2board3board4
Still, we would be remiss if we left things all rosy and glowing, because this prince has a few warts. For those of you who didn't read the first article, we decided to forgo a full blown review of the PX1 Extreme primarily because ECS's left hand didn't know what its right hand was doing.

That might sound unkind, but it's in essence the truth here. ECS's support website and even their own support engineers in Taiwan apparently didn't realize they had no workable BIOS flash utility to go with this board. Their initial BIOS release came packaged with AWDFLASH, which is NOT the flash utility this board needs. As such, we and other review sites ended up either unable to update BIOS's to give a real up to date evaluation of the board, or ended up destroying boards with AWDFLASH. It took several trying weeks of back and forth emails and phone calls not to mention replacement boards being shipped, before we actually had the capability to update BIOS's properly.

Let's move on now, and take a look at the actual latest BIOS, and see if any of our initial concerns with the boards first shipping BIOS were met.



 
© 2003-2008 Fastsilicon Media. All Rights Reserved